IRA Rollovers: Yes, Rolling Over Your 401(k) Into An IRA Is Smart!

Changing careers? Deciding what to do with retirement funds is going to be a primary concern. While there are a number of options available, many choose to roll these funds over into an Individual Retirement Account.

There are a number of good reasons for this, and we'll be looking at seven of them here in a minute. But first ...

What Exactly is a Rollover IRA?

IRA rollovers can be deposited into an IRA from another retirement fund, such as a 401(k). Those who don’t already have an IRA can open one for the express purpose of rolling over funds from a previous employer’s retirement plan. Those who already have an IRA can simply roll over the money into the existing IRA.

IRA Rollovers

7 Reasons an IRA Rollover Makes Sense

Many folks are content to let their 401(k) plans accrue money over time, and there’s nothing wrong with that option. Why would you fix something that isn’t broke?

Well in this instance, you would not be fixing something that is broken so much as replacing it with something better.

What do we mean?

Those who have just switched jobs have a short list of options concerning their retirement funds. These include:

Cashing the funds out immediately is not advisable. While leaving the money in the original 401(k) or rolling it over into the new one aren’t bad options, there are a number of reasons why an IRA rollover is the best option on the list.

Reason #1: Rollovers Can Preserve Tax-Favored Status

Those who choose to cash out their accounts early are not only subject to a 10% early withdrawal penalty if they are under the age of 59 ½ but will also need to pay income tax on the balance.

By contrast, rollovers can preserve tax-favored status so long as they’re transferred from one trustee to another. In other words, the IRA will continue to grow tax-deferred until a retiree begins collecting on their investment.

Reason #2: IRA Rollovers Can Increase Investment Options

Some folks choose to leave the funds in their old plan alone or roll the funds over into a new employer-offered plan. There’s nothing wrong with this per se, but rolling the money over into an IRA can increase the number of options that are available to you. For instance, IRAs typically offer a broader range of investments. 401(k) plans, on the other hand, may be limited to a handful of mutual funds.

This advantage will contribute to a better investment strategy and can prove more lucrative in the long run.

Reason #3: IRAs Have Lower Fees

Generally speaking, employer-sponsored 401(k) plans typically have higher administrative fees than IRAs.

Reason #4: An IRA Centralizes Control of Your Retirement Monies

There might some good reasons to keep your old 401(k) open, particularly if you’re satisfied with the returns. On the other hand, it’s much more convenient to have one centralized location from which to manage all of your retirement funds. IRAs are easy to figure out and significantly reduce the complexity of managing separate accounts.

From one centralized location you can access:

Reason #5: Brokers Will Compete For Your Business

Brokerage firms are more than willing to offer incentives to bring your business to them. In some instances, this could even mean free cash. In other instances, you may be entitled to free trades. It’s certainly something to look into as you figure out how you want to invest your retirement money.

Reason #6: 401(k) Plans are Subject to Rules an Individual Company Establishes

Every company has a great deal of wiggle room when it comes to setting up a 401(k) plan for their employees. IRAs, on the other hand, are subject to a centralized set of rules established by the IRS.

This is better for two reasons:

Reason #7: The Rollover Itself is Free

While there are other costs to consider, rolling over a 401(k) into an IRA is free. There will be transaction costs for individual investments and other costs to bear in mind, but setting up and rolling over the money is a relatively pain-free process.

The Bottom Line

The advantages of rolling over your 401(k) into an IRA far exceed the risks. It makes sense not because the other options are bad, but simply because IRAs are better for some. With more investment options to choose from, lower administrative costs associated with the account, a simple centralized location from which to access your retirement investments, and more transparency regarding how the fund operates, IRAs make the most sense  for your retirement plan.

IRA Rollovers: Yes, Rolling Over Your 401(k) Into An IRA Is Smart!

Changing careers? Deciding what to do with retirement funds is going to be a primary concern. While there are a number of options available, many choose to roll these funds over into an Individual Retirement Account.

There are a number of good reasons for this.

What Exactly is a Rollover IRA?

IRA Rollovers can be deposited into an IRA from another retirement fund, for instance: a 401(k). Those who don’t already have an IRA can open one for the express purpose of rolling over funds from a previous employer’s retirement plan. Those who already have an IRA can simply roll over the money into the existing IRA.

The Benefits of an IRA Rollover

Many folks are content to let their 401(k) plans accrue money over time, and there’s nothing wrong with that option. Why would you fix something that isn’t broke? Well in this instance, you would not be fixing something that is broken so much as replacing it with something better.

What do we mean?

Those who have just switched jobs have a short list of options concerning their retirement funds. These include:

Cashing the funds out immediately is not advisable. While leaving the money in the original 401(k) or rolling it over into the new one aren’t bad options, there are a number of reasons why an IRA rollover is the best option on the list.

Rollovers Can Preserve Tax-Favored Status

Those who choose to cash out their accounts early are not only subject to a 10% early withdrawal penalty if they are under the age of 59 ½ but will also need to pay income tax on the balance.

By contrast, rollovers can preserve tax-favored status so long as they’re transferred from one trustee to another. In other words, the IRA will continue to grow tax-deferred until a retiree begins collecting on their investment.

IRA Rollovers Can Increase Investment Options

Some folks choose to leave the funds in their old plan alone or roll the funds over into a new employer-offered plan. There’s nothing wrong with this per se, but rolling the money over into an IRA can increase the number of options that are available to you. For instance, IRAs typically offer a broader range of investments. 401(k) plans, on the other hand, may be limited to a handful of mutual funds.

This advantage will contribute to a better investment strategy and can prove more lucrative in the long run.

IRAs Have Lower Fees

Generally speaking, employer-sponsored 401(k) plans typically have higher administrative fees than IRAs.

An IRA Centralizes Control of Your Retirement Monies

There might some good reasons to keep your old 401(k) open, particularly if you’re satisfied with the returns. On the other hand, it’s much more convenient to have one centralized location from which to manage all of your retirement funds. IRAs are easy to figure out and significantly reduce the complexity of managing separate accounts.
From one centralized location you can access:

Brokers Will Compete For Your Business

Brokerage firms are more than willing to offer incentives to bring your business to them. In some instances, this could even mean free cash. In other instances, you may be entitled to free trades. It’s certainly something to look into as you figure out how you want to invest your retirement money.

401(k) Plans are Subject to Rules an Individual Company Establishes

Every company has a great deal of wiggle room when it comes to setting up a 401(k) plan for their employees. IRAs, on the other hand, are subject to a centralized set of rules established by the IRS.

This is better for two reasons:

The Rollover Itself is Free

While there are other costs to consider, rolling over a 401(k) into an IRA is free. There will be transaction costs for individual investments and other costs to bear in mind, but setting up and rolling over the money is a relatively pain-free process.

The Bottom Line

The advantages of rolling over your 401(k) into an IRA far exceed the risks. It makes sense not because the other options are bad, but simply because IRAs are better for some. With more investment options to choose from, lower administrative costs associated with the account, a simple centralized location from which to access your retirement investments, and more transparency regarding how the fund operates, IRAs make the most sense  for your retirement plan.

IRA Rollovers, Explained

An IRA rollover is a transfer of funds from one retirement account a traditional IRA or Roth IRA.

IRA Rollovers are defined as tax-free transfers of retirement from one type of investment account to another. Rollovers were originally introduced to increase the mobility of qualified plan funds for employees moving from one job to another.

You can find the basic provisions governing rollover transfers here. These provisions cover transfers from one IRA to another, transfers from qualified pension, profit-sharing, stock bonus, and annuity plans to IRAs, and transfers from IRAs to qualified plans.

There are a few rare exceptions to the rollover rules. For example, in certain situations, an IRA can make a rollover distribution to a health savings account (HSA).

In other words, if you receive a distribution from a qualified plan (such as a 401(k)), you might decide to put some or all of the distribution amount into an IRA. The IRA that receives the qualified plan distribution is called a rollover IRA.

You can do this either through a direct transfer or via check. If you do a rollover via check, your custodian will write you a check, which you will then deposit into the other account.

How Often Can I Do a Rollover?

The privilege of rolling over from IRA to IRA may be exercised only once in a 12-month period.

Can You Rollover Funds From a Traditional IRA to Another Traditional IRA?

Yes, as long as the money being moved is withdrawn from your old account and deposited in another account within 60 days. Failing to follow this rule can cause your rollover to lose tax-deferred status and cost you big time.

This rule operates on an all or nothing basis. The entire amount received from your old IRA must be transferred to the designated IRA. If you pocket anything, the rollover rule does not apply, and everything received from the old IRA, including any amount transferred to another IRA, is treated as a taxable distribution.

What If I'm Transferring Property That Isn't Money?

If property other than money is received from your old IRA, that property, (not substitute property of equal value or the cash proceeds of the property's sale), must be included in the transfer to the new IRA.

Note: According to our friends at the Tax Court, the rollover contribution must be of cash if the distribution is in cash.

Can I Rollover Funds From a Qualified Plan to a Traditional IRA?

Yes. A qualified plan (or annuity participant) can roll over any distribution other than a distribution that:

 Note: An employee's surviving spouse may also roll over a similar distribution received on account of the employee's death.

Can a Traditional IRA be Rolled Into a Qualified Plan?

Yes. Within 60 days after the distribution, an IRA can be rolled into an eligible retirement plan for the distributee's benefit.

The term “eligible retirement plan” includes:

A rollover contribution must include the entire amount received in the distribution, but it may not exceed the portion of the distribution that, in the absence of the rollover, would be included in the distributee's gross income.

Can I Rollover a Traditional IRA I inherited?

No, usually. A taxpayer whose interest in an IRA is as a beneficiary of the person who created the IRA is usually denied the privilege of rolling over tax free from the IRA to another type IRA or a qualified plan or tax deferred annuity.

Rare exception: a surviving spouse may roll over to another IRA but not a qualified plan.

So why isn't this usually allowed? Because the tax allowances for IRAs (including an IRA’s tax exemption) are intended to encourage saving for the retirement of the contributor and surviving spouse.

Blame Congress. They're the ones who decided it was inappropriate to allow the tax exemption to be prolonged by rollovers after the contributor has died and the account has passed into the hands of a person other than a surviving spouse.

Are There Reporting Requirements For Traditional IRA Holders?

Yes. But don't worry, it's not that bad! (Hopefully you have someone else doing the paperwork for you.) Individuals maintaining IRAs and surviving beneficiaries under IRAs must usually file an annual information return on Form 5329.

Also, an individual maintaining an IRA must make an information filing for each year in which a nondeductible IRA contribution is made or a distribution is received from an IRA.

The filing, which must be included with the individual's return for the year, must disclose the following:

What Will The IRS do if You Fail To File Properly?

A $50 penalty is assessed for not filing, unless you can justify why you didn't. Also, because non-deductible contributions are recoverable tax free upon distribution, the IRS will want $100 if these contributions are overstated in the return and you, the taxpayer, cannot justify the overstatement.

I hope this article answered any questions you may have had. If you have any questions about IRA rollovers feel free to ask me, I'd love to help you.