5 Pros and 5 Cons of a Self-Directed 401(k)

Today, many Americans rely on the 401k plans set up by their employer as a means of saving for their eventual retirement. A 401k plan allows you to use your pre-tax dollars to invest in mutual funds, as well stocks, bonds, and Target Date funds. Most likely, a firm contracted by your employer manages your 401k plan. Often, the funds in these 401k accounts are automatically invested per your employer or managing firm’s direction. However, did you know there was a way to have more control and be more involved with your 401k investments? A self-directed 401k offers you more control, flexibility, and investment diversity. Before opening one of these specialized types of 401k plans, take a look at the pros and cons below.

The Pros

  • As with your employer’s 401k plan, contributions, investment returns and any earning are all tax-deferred. Your employer continues to receive the same benefits as they would through their selected 401k plan as well.
  • You are still in control of your voluntary contribution. This means that you are still able to use your pre-tax dollars to invest in your self-directed 401k plan and benefit from the income tax benefits associated with your reduced post-tax wages. If your employer matches or contributes a percentage to your standard 401k plan, they can continue to do so with your self-directed 401k as well.
  • For your 2018 taxes, you will be able to defer taxes on up to $18,500 on your annual earnings. (This is a $500 increase from your 2017 taxes!) After the age of 50, you can make catch up contributions up to $6,000.
  • One of the biggest benefits of a self-directed 401k plan is the personal control you have over your investments and the types of things you can invest in. Like a self-directed IRA, you can invest in almost anything. This includes real estate, precious metals, and private placements. (Your employer’s 401k does not permit these types of investments and thus limit your portfolio’s diversity.)
  • When you change employers, your previous 401k will need to be closed and new accounts, as selected by your new company, will be opened. With a self-directed 401k, however, this is not so. You can roll these accounts to your new employer instead of having to establish a new one.

The Cons

  • As with your employer’s 401k plan, any withdrawals from your self-directed 401k before the age of 59 ½ will suffer a 10% tax penalty.
  • Just like the 401k plan established by your employer, contributions made by your employer to a self-directed 401k may be subject to eligibility requirements. For example, some employers only partially match your contributions for the first year of your employment. Others may only match contributions for full-time employees. These eligibility requirements are dictated primarily by your employer and not your 401k plan itself.
  • You need to have an optional range of index funds in order to have the best long-term investment portfolio.
  • Self-directed 401k plans can be more expensive to open and manage.
  • Investment options for your self-directed 401k may be limited in both scope and quality. Be vigilant with your investments and do your research.

Royal Legal Solutions Can Help You

Royal Legal Solutions has many years of experience with Solo 401(k) plans. As a firm that specializes in accounts that give the owner more options, flexibility and control – we understand how important your investment choices are for your future finances.  

Scott Royal Smith is an asset protection attorney and long-time real estate investor. He's on a mission to help fellow investors free their time, protect their assets, and create lasting wealth.

Discuss the legal safety of your real estate investment portfolio?

Give Our Real Legal Team a Call Now!

(512) 871-0843